The biography of Schumann 1810-1841

Robert Schumann was born in Zwickau on June 8, 1810, the youngest of five children. His father was a bookseller, publisher, and author. Robert received his first piano instruction at the age of six or seven, his teacher the city organist Johann Gottfried Kuntsch, with whom Schumann would have a lifelong friendship. Early on he organized concerts with other available musicians, conducted them himself and played missing parts on the piano. At the age of twelve he composed his first compositions, the “150th Psalm” and “Overture with Chorus” for orchestra, soloists, and chorus with obligato piano, the latter played by Schumann who also conducted the work.
An additional creative province was literature. His father’s bookshop gave him access to the newest works of poets, as well as the newest musical compositions. Schumann wrote poems, speeches, and essays, and devoured works by colleagues like Goethe, Schiller, Hölderlin, Byron, Shakespeare, and later Jean Paul. Schumann was fourteen years old when his older sister committed suicide. At sixteen he lost his father, who had encouraged Robert’s musical inclinations and shortly before his death had recommended him to Carl Maria von Weber. Schumann’s character was altered: he became quieter and lived more within himself.

During the summer of 1827 he met Agnes Carus, the wife of a medical doctor. Through her musical enthusiasm he became acquainted with the Schubert Lieder that stimulated his own first song compositions and Polonaises for four-hands. His friend Emil Flechsig reminisced later about this time: “He conceived a great partiality for Schubert, who was then in 1828 just becoming known, and collected everything by him that was to be had…When Schubert died the following year, he was so upset by the news that I heard him sobbing all night long.”
After graduating from Gymnasium with honors Schumann went to Leipzig to study law as his mother and guardian wished. But there he also took piano lessons from Friedrich Wieck, performed intensively (Schubert’s Piano Trio in E-flat), and composed an attractive Piano Quintet. At the age of 19 he resettled in Heidelberg and first appeared there as a pianist. Over Easter he experienced Paganini in Frankfurt, who “greatly inspired my diligence, but was wanting in terms of elevated, noble, and priestly artistic repose.”

His commitment to music as a profession dates from this period, and he produced the Abegg Variations, op. 1, Papillons, op. 2, and the first version of the Toccata, op. 7. Schumann’s first published compositions were limited to works for piano. When he returned to Leipzig he officially concluded his law studies, and again took up piano lessons with Friedrich Wieck. In addition he took theory instruction from the music director Heinrich Dorn. However, soon afterwards both teachers proved disappointments. In his diary he wrote about Wieck: “He is truly an ill-tempered man. When Allwin  (Wieck’s young son) didn’t play well, [Wieck] threw him to the ground, pulled him by the hair, all the while  shaking and staggering…Zilia (Clara Wieck, daughter from his first marriage, and a highly gifted pianist) just smiled through all of this, sitting down quietly at the piano to play a Weber Sonata. Am I among human beings here?” And as for the compositions of his theory teacher: “Dorn’s music. It is as futile as dogs trying to catch birds. Rabbits you can shoot dead, but you cannot strangle a lion.”  He sent the following lines to his old teacher in Zwickau: “Bach’s Well-Tempered Clavier is my textbook, the absolute best. I have analyzed the fugues one after the other down to the finest detail, for Bach was a complete being—he did nothing halfway or weakly, and everything was composed for the ages.”

Excessive practice had left Schumann with a lamed middle finger, a fate that resulted in an intensification of his activity as a composer. At the same time he began work as a musical journalist with the publication of an enthusiastic article about Frédéric Chopin. In his notebook he wrote: "A magazine for 'music to come' is still lacking. The only suitable editors would be men like the old blind cantor of the Thomasschule [Bach] and the deaf Viennese Kapellmeister [Beethoven]." In 1834, when Schumann was twenty-four years old, he founded his own magazine, the Neue Zeitschrift für Musik, which he turned into one of the leading journals in Germany. "On stage Rossini still ruled, and on the piano exclusively [Henri] Herz and [Franz] Hünten. This despite the fact that only a few years had passed since Beethoven, C. M. von Weber and Franz Schubert had lived amongst us. To be sure Mendelssohn's star was on the rise, and wonderful things were rumored about a Pole named Chopin, but their ultimate influence had not yet made itself manifest," wrote Schumann much later in an introduction to a new edition of articles in book form. His discernment in regard to other composers was extraordinary; the above-mentioned composers became widely known through his articles and his impulse for discovery. In this way Schumann found Schubert's Symphony in C major at Schubert's brother's house in Vienna, which he sent to Mendelssohn for the world premiere. About Richard Wagner he wrote: "He could be of great import for the stage, and if I have judged him right, he has the courage to do it." His visionary conviction discovered Johannes Brahms, of whom he wrote the famous 1853 article "New Paths." Far more well-read than other composers, Schumann could also discern literary wheat from chaff.
He wrote his articles from the viewpoints of different characters. Eusebius was his term for the rational, sensitive side, which "rapturously but deliberately plucks one flower petal after another." Florestan was the powerful, enthusiastic side, that "saw the future, the novel and unusual far in advance," while Master Raro was the mediator, who "used the yardstick of masters and masterworks to evaluate his own accomplishments." In Schumann's diary August 14th, the day he was engaged to his future wife Clara, was Eusebius Day.  "And here I shall name another union, one that was very secret, and existed only in the head of its creator, namely the Davidsbündler. In presenting different viewpoints of artistic perception it was convenient to invent opposing artistic characters, of which Florestan and Eusebius were the most important and between whom stood the mediating Master Raro. This brotherhood of Davidsbündler was a reoccurring theme in the magazine, combining 'truth and poetry' in humorous fashion."

Henriette Voigt, who had met Schumann through his friend, the pianist Ludwig Schuncke (who died young), introduced the composer to Ernestine von Fricken, a pupil of Schumann’s own piano teacher Friedrich Wieck. Schumann fell in love with the young woman. Letters to Henriette Voigt soon voiced doubts about this liaison, though Friedrich Wieck supported the infatuation to divert Schumann’s attention from his daughter Clara. Ernestine would later support Clara and Robert’s relationship in their struggle with Wieck.
Schumann, at 25, lived in Leipzig, and was aware that he would be neither lawyer, as his mother had wished, nor author, but rather pianist or composer. He felt himself irresistibly attracted to Clara Wieck, the daughter of his piano teacher. Papa Wieck forbade any contact between the two, even letters were not allowed. Her life was dedicated to her concert career, with papa as her manager. At this time, music became more than ever Schumann’s method of communication. His mother’s death added to his inner turmoil.

He completed three sonatas, each with its own primal motif threaded through the entire work, which surfaces in the finest nuances and shadings of variation. This “Schumann style” is most evident in the sonatas. Nevertheless, each of the three works has an entirely individual expression. Schumann's "Piano Sonata no. 1 in F-sharp minor," Op. 11 was dedicated to Clara  Wieck, who reacted enthusiastically after first reading through it. Franz Liszt regarded the work as the best of its genre since Beethoven. The Sonata in F minor is the darkest and most troubled of Schumann’s works. The Sonata in G minor, op. 22, is the shortest and most transparent (apart from the original Finale Presto, without opus number) of his three sonatas.

The first sketch for the Fantasie, op. 17, occurred at the time of Schumann’s enforced separation from Clara Wieck. At the beginning of the Davidsbündlertänze op.6 he quoted Clara Wieck’s Marzurka, op. 6, no. 5. Afterwards followed two books of nine dances each.

In August of the year 1838 Clara conzertized extensively in Leipzig. She included pieces from the Symphonic Etudes, op. 13, an important sign for Robert Schumann after long years of disappointment. He wrote her, “… answer me with a simple ‘yes.’” Two days later she replied: “…how could a heart so full of unspoken love as mine not speak the short word aloud? I do so, and my deepest self whispers it to you eternally…” However, her father rejected the match, and attempted to get rid of Schumann. The latter’s entreaties were made with new energy. 

He was often forced to finance publication of his works with his own money. The magazine also required a great deal of labor. Over the seven years of his involvement, in  addition to myriad articles he wrote approximately 3,000 business letters. His beloved Clara Wieck traveled with her father to Vienna and enjoyed a great success, though exclusively with the bravura repertoire typical of the time. The Kinderszenen, op. 15, appeared at the beginning of 1838, and soon found widespread distribution. The Träumerei from this cycle of a total of thirteen pieces remains Schumann’s best-known piece even today. As counterpart to Kinderszenen he produced Kreisleriana, op. 16, in which he “invested a real, proper, and wild love.”

In autumn of 1838 Schumann traveled to Vienna, vainly attempting to establish himself during a half-year stay. His most important experience there was the discovery of Schubert’s C major Symphony, which he immediately sent to Mendelssohn in Leipzig for its world premiere. Schumann regarded it as the greatest work composed since Beethoven. He also wrote, “I often feel like crushing the piano, which seems too limited a vehicle for my ideas.” After attempts at quartets and piano concerti he finally composed the last works of his so-called Piano Period: Arabeske op. 18, Blumenstück op. 19, Humoreske op. 20, Faschingsschwank aus Wien op. 26, Nachtstücke op. 23, Romanzen op. 28, and Klavierstücke op. 32.

At the beginning of the year 1839 Clara traveled to Paris, this time without her father Friedrich Wieck. In fact, the two young people decided to initiate a lawsuit against Wieck in order to arrange their marriage with out his consent. Clara's mother Marianne Bargiel, divorced from Friedrich Wieck and living in Berlin, threw her support to the young pair. An attempt at mediating the dispute ended without success. Wieck's complaints of inflicted illness and defamation influenced both court and public opinion, and provoked a dangerous crisis in Schumann's health. For a time he was hardly able to compose. At a friend's intervention he was awarded a doctorate from the University of Jena, which somewhat improved his standing in the court case against Wieck. After a number of episodes Schumann received the approval of the courts for the marriage to Clara in August, 1840 (and Wieck was sentenced to 18 days in jail for slander). On September 12, the evening before Clara's twenty-first birthday, the wedding was celebrated in the village church of Schönefeld (Leipzig). The Lieder cycle "Myrthen" would be Schumann's wedding present to Clara.

Translation: William Melton
                                                                                                                                                                © Franz Vorraber